Legislation – Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024
Part 3Enforcement of consumer protection law
Chapter 3Consumer protection orders and undertakings
Enforcers for purposes of Chapter
151Enforcers
(1)
Each of the following is a public designated enforcer for the purposes of this Chapter—
(a)
the CMA;
(b)
every local weights and measures authority in Great Britain;
(c)
the Department for the Economy in Northern Ireland;
(d)
the Civil Aviation Authority;
(e)
the Financial Conduct Authority;
(f)
the Gas and Electricity Markets Authority;
(g)
the Department of Health in Northern Ireland;
(h)
the Department for Infrastructure in Northern Ireland;
(i)
the Northern Ireland Authority for Utility Regulation;
(j)
an enforcement authority within the meaning of section 120(15) of the Communications Act 2003 (regulation of premium rate services);
(k)
the Information Commissioner;
(l)
the Maritime and Coastguard Agency;
(m)
the Office of Communications;
(n)
the Office of Rail and Road;
(o)
the Office for the Traffic Commissioner;
(p)
the Secretary of State;
(q)
the Water Services Regulation Authority.
(2)
The Consumers’ Association is a private designated enforcer for the purposes of this Chapter.
(3)
The Secretary of State may by regulations amend subsection (1) or (2) so as to—
(a)
add or remove a person as a public designated enforcer;
(b)
add or remove a person as a private designated enforcer;
(c)
vary the entry of a person as a public or private designated enforcer.
(4)
The power under subsection (3)(a) to add a person as a public designated enforcer is exercisable only if the Secretary of State considers that the person is a public body that has, as one of their purposes, the protection of the collective interests of consumers.
(5)
The power under subsection (3)(b) to add a person as a private designated enforcer is exercisable only if the Secretary of State considers that the person—
(a)
is not a public body,
(b)
satisfies the designation criteria in section 152, and
(c)
has, as one of their purposes, the protection of the collective interests of consumers.
(6)
(7)
Regulations under this section are subject to the affirmative procedure.
152Designation criteria
(1)
These are the designation criteria in respect of a person (“P”) for the purposes of section 151(5)(b)—
(a)
P is constituted, managed and controlled in such a way as to be expected to act independently, impartially and with integrity;
(b)
P has established procedures to ensure that any potential conflicts of interest are properly dealt with;
(c)
P has demonstrated experience, competence and expertise in promoting or protecting the collective interests of consumers;
(d)
P has demonstrated the ability to protect the interests of consumers by promoting high standards of integrity and fair dealing in the conduct of business in relation to consumers;
(e)
P has the capability to investigate infringements and carry out enforcement procedures under this Chapter;
(f)
P is ready and willing to follow best practice in enforcement;
(g)
P is ready and willing to co-operate with other enforcers and relevant persons.
(2)
P does not fail to meet the criteria in subsection (1)(a) by reason only of a connection with another person carrying on a business of a kind that could be affected (directly or indirectly) by action taken under this Chapter if—
(a)
the other person does not control P, and
(b)
the profits of the other person’s business are used for the purposes of furthering the objectives of P.
(3)
For the purposes of subsection (1)(g)—
(a)
“relevant persons” are any persons responsible for the regulation of matters in respect of which acts or omissions may constitute a relevant infringement;
(b)
co-operation includes, in particular—
(i)
sharing of information (so far as legally permitted), and
(ii)
participating in arrangements to co-ordinate action under this Part.
Applications for enforcement orders and interim enforcement orders
153Applications
(1)
An enforcer may (subject to subsection (2)) apply to the appropriate court for an enforcement order or an interim enforcement order if the enforcer considers that—
(a)
a person has engaged in, is engaging in or is likely to engage in a commercial practice which constitutes a relevant infringement, or
(b)
a person is an accessory to such a practice.
(2)
An enforcer may make an application in respect of a relevant infringement only if—
(a)
in the case of a commercial practice in breach of an enactment listed in the first column of the Table in Part 1 of Schedule 15, the enforcer is an authorised enforcer in respect of that enactment in accordance with the second column of that Table;
(b)
in the case of a commercial practice in breach of an obligation or rule of law listed in the first column of the Table in Part 2 of Schedule 15, the enforcer is an authorised enforcer in respect of that obligation or rule of law in accordance with the second column of that Table.
(3)
An application for an enforcement order or an interim enforcement order—
(a)
must be made in respect of the person the enforcer considers falls within subsection (1)(a) or (b) (“the respondent”), and
(b)
must (where known) name the respondent.
(4)
An application by a public designated enforcer for an enforcement order may, subject to subsection (5), include an application for the respondent to pay a monetary penalty.
(5)
In the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(a), an application under subsection (4) may be made only in respect of a commercial practice that the enforcer considers a person has engaged, or is engaging, in (but not in respect of a practice that the enforcer considers a person is likely to engage in).
154CMA directions to other enforcers
(1)
This section applies where it appears to the CMA that another enforcer intends to make an application for an enforcement order or an interim enforcement order.
(2)
The CMA may direct that an application for such an order in respect of a particular relevant infringement—
(a)
may be made only by the CMA,
(b)
may be made only by such other enforcer as may be specified in the direction, or
(c)
is not to be made by any enforcer.
(3)
A direction under subsection (2)—
(a)
does not prevent the acceptance of an undertaking under section 163 by the CMA or another enforcer;
(b)
does not prevent the CMA from taking such other steps as it considers appropriate for the purpose of securing that the infringement is not committed, continued or repeated.
(4)
A direction under subsection (2)(c) may be made—
(a)
only in respect of an infringement that is a relevant infringement for the purposes of Chapter 4 (in addition to being a relevant infringement for the purposes of this Chapter), and
(b)
only if the CMA is conducting, or proposes to conduct, an investigation under section 180 in relation to that infringement.
(5)
A direction under this section may be varied or withdrawn.
(6)
The CMA must take such steps as it considers appropriate to bring a direction (or its variation or withdrawal) to the attention of enforcers likely to be affected by it.
155Consultation
(1)
Before making an application for an enforcement order or an interim enforcement order, an enforcer must (subject to subsection (5)) engage in appropriate consultation with the person in respect of whom the order would be made (“the respondent”).
(2)
Consultation is “appropriate consultation” for the purposes of subsection (1) if it is carried out for the purposes of—
(a)
achieving the cessation of a relevant infringement (in a case where the infringement is occurring) and ensuring it does not recur;
(b)
ensuring there is no repetition of a relevant infringement in a case where the infringement has occurred;
(c)
ensuring that a relevant infringement does not take place in a case where the infringement has yet to occur;
(d)
ensuring, in the case of consultation carried out by a public designated enforcer, that the respondent is aware that an application for an enforcement order may include an application for the respondent to pay a monetary penalty.
(3)
Engagement under subsection (1) must be initiated by the giving of a consultation request to the respondent.
(4)
A consultation request must be given by notice in writing.
(5)
The requirement to consult under this section does not apply if—
(a)
the CMA considers that an application for the order in question should be made without delay, or
(b)
it is not reasonably practicable for the enforcer to ascertain the identity and whereabouts of the respondent.
(6)
The requirement to consult under this section ceases to apply—
(a)
in the case of an application for an enforcement order, at the end of the applicable period;
(b)
in the case of an application for an interim enforcement order, at the end of the period of 7 days beginning with the day after the respondent receives a consultation request.
(7)
In subsection (6)(a) the “applicable period” means—
(a)
in a case where the respondent is a member of, or is represented by, an approved representative body, the period of 28 days beginning with the day after the respondent receives a consultation request;
(b)
in any other case, the period of 14 days beginning with the day after the respondent receives a consultation request.
(8)
In subsection (7)(a) “approved representative body” means a representative body that operates a consumer code which has been approved by—
(a)
a public designated enforcer,
(b)
a body which represents a public designated enforcer,
(c)
a group of public designated enforcers, or
(d)
a community interest company whose objects include the approval of consumer codes.
(9)
In subsection (8)—
“consumer code” means an agreement or set of rules regulating, with a view to safeguarding or promoting the interests of consumers, the behaviour of traders who—
(a)
are engaged in commercial practices, and
(b)
choose to be bound by the agreement or set of rules;
“representative body” means an organisation established to represent the interests of two or more businesses in a particular sector or area.
Powers of court on application under section 153
156Enforcement orders and undertakings
(1)
This section applies if, on an application under section 153 for an enforcement order, the court finds that the person in respect of whom the application is made (“the respondent”)—
(a)
has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice which constitutes a relevant infringement (“the infringing practice”), or
(b)
is an accessory to the infringing practice.
(2)
The court may—
(a)
make an enforcement order against the respondent, or
(b)
accept an undertaking from the respondent given under subsection (5).
(3)
In considering whether to make an enforcement order the court must have regard to whether the respondent—
(a)
has given an undertaking under section 163 or 185 in respect of the infringing practice, and
(b)
if so, whether the respondent has failed to comply with the undertaking.
(4)
An enforcement order is an order that—
(a)
indicates the nature of the infringing practice, and
(b)
directs the respondent to comply with subsection (6).
(5)
The respondent gives an undertaking under this subsection by undertaking—
(a)
to comply with subsection (6), or
(b)
to take steps which the court believes will secure that the respondent complies with subsection (6).
(6)
The respondent complies with this subsection by—
(a)
in the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(a), not continuing or repeating the infringing practice (where it is alleged that the person has engaged or is engaging in that practice);
(b)
in the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(b), not consenting to or conniving in the infringing practice;
(c)
in either case, not engaging in the infringing practice in the course of the respondent’s business or another business;
(d)
in either case, not consenting to or conniving in the carrying out of the infringing practice by a body corporate with which the respondent has a special relationship (see section 220).
(7)
See also—
(a)
section 157 about the inclusion of enhanced consumer measures in an enforcement order or undertaking;
(b)
section 158 about the inclusion of a requirement to pay a monetary penalty in an enforcement order.
(8)
An enforcement order may require the respondent to publish—
(a)
the order;
(b)
a corrective statement.
(9)
An undertaking under subsection (5) may include a further undertaking by the respondent to publish—
(a)
the terms of the undertaking;
(b)
a corrective statement.
(10)
Publication under subsection (8) or (9)—
(a)
must be made in such form and manner, and to such extent, as the court considers appropriate for the purpose of eliminating any continuing effects of the conduct in respect of which the order was made or undertaking given;
(b)
is not an enhanced consumer measure for the purposes of this Chapter.
(11)
Where the court has accepted from the respondent an undertaking under subsection (5)—
(a)
the court may accept from the respondent any variation of the undertaking that the court considers appropriate for meeting the purposes for which the undertaking was given;
(b)
the court may release the respondent from the undertaking (whether on its own initiative or at the respondent’s request) if the court considers that the undertaking is no longer necessary to further those purposes.
157Enforcement orders and undertakings: enhanced consumer measures
(1)
An enforcement order or undertaking may include a requirement to take such enhanced consumer measures as the court considers just and reasonable.
(2)
For this purpose, the court must in particular consider whether any proposed enhanced consumer measures are proportionate having regard to—
(a)
the likely benefit of the measures to consumers,
(b)
the costs likely to be incurred by the respondent, and
(c)
the likely cost to consumers of obtaining the benefit of the measures.
(3)
The costs referred to in subsection (2)(b) are—
(a)
the cost of the measures, and
(b)
the reasonable administrative costs associated with taking the measures.
(4)
Where the respondent is required under an enforcement order or an undertaking to take enhanced consumer measures, the order or undertaking may include requirements for the respondent to provide information or documents to the court in order that the court may determine whether the respondent is taking those measures.
(5)
Subsection (6) applies if—
(a)
an enforcement order or undertaking includes enhanced consumer measures offering compensation, and
(b)
a settlement agreement is entered into in connection with the payment of compensation.
(6)
A waiver of a person’s rights in the settlement agreement is not valid if it is a waiver of the right to bring civil proceedings in respect of conduct other than conduct which has given rise to the enforcement order or undertaking.
(7)
This section is subject to section 177 (private designated enforcers).
(8)
In this section “undertaking” means an undertaking given under section 156(5).
(9)
References in this Part to “enhanced consumer measures” are to be read in accordance with section 221.
158Enforcement orders: requirement to pay monetary penalty
(1)
This section applies where the court makes an enforcement order against the respondent on an application made by a public designated enforcer.
(2)
The order may, subject to subsection (3), include a requirement for the respondent to pay a monetary penalty.
(3)
In the case of a respondent within section 156(1)(a), a requirement to pay a monetary penalty may be imposed only if the court finds that the respondent has engaged, or is engaging, in a commercial practice constituting a relevant infringement (and not in respect of a practice that the court finds that the person is likely to engage in).
(4)
Where the order includes a requirement under subsection (2), the order, or a notice accompanying service of the order, must set out the monetary penalty information (see section 203).
(5)
The amount of a monetary penalty must be a fixed amount not exceeding £300,000 or, if higher, 10% of the total value of the turnover (if any) of the respondent.
(6)
A monetary penalty may not be imposed on the respondent by virtue of this section in respect of any conduct that constitutes an offence if the respondent has been found guilty of that offence.
(7)
The respondent does not commit an offence in relation to any conduct in respect of which a monetary penalty is imposed on the respondent by virtue of this section.
(8)
In addition to any right of appeal on a point of law, a person liable to pay a monetary penalty by virtue of this section may appeal in respect of—
(a)
the decision to impose the penalty, or
(b)
the nature or amount of the penalty.
(9)
In the application of subsection (4) to Scotland, “service of the order” includes service of an extract order in execution of or diligence on the order.
159Interim enforcement orders and undertakings
(1)
This section applies if—
(a)
it is alleged in an application under section 153 for an interim enforcement order that a person (“the respondent”)—
(i)
has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice which constitutes a relevant infringement (“the infringing practice”), or
(ii)
is an accessory to the infringing practice,
(b)
it appears to the court that if the application had been an application for an enforcement order it would be likely to be granted, and
(c)
the court considers it is expedient that the infringing practice is prohibited or prevented immediately.
(2)
The court may—
(a)
make an interim enforcement order against the respondent, or
(b)
accept an undertaking from the respondent to comply with subsection (5) or to take steps which the court believes will secure such compliance.
(3)
If no notice of the application has been given to the respondent, the court may proceed under subsection (2)(a) only if it considers it appropriate to make an interim enforcement order without notice.
(4)
An interim enforcement order is an order that—
(a)
indicates the nature of the infringing practice, and
(b)
directs the respondent to comply with subsection (5).
(5)
The respondent complies with this subsection by—
(a)
in the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(a)(i), not continuing or repeating the infringing practice (where it is alleged that the person has engaged or is engaging in that practice);
(b)
in the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(a)(ii), not consenting to or conniving in the infringing practice;
(c)
in either case, not engaging in the infringing practice in the course of the respondent’s business or another business;
(d)
in either case, not consenting to or conniving in the carrying out of the infringing practice by a body corporate with which the respondent has a special relationship (see section 220).
(6)
An application for an interim enforcement order in respect of alleged conduct of the respondent may not be made at any time after—
(a)
an application for an enforcement order against the respondent in respect of that conduct is determined, or
(b)
a final infringement notice in respect of that conduct has been given to the respondent (see section 182).
(7)
An application for an interim enforcement order must—
(a)
include all information known to the applicant that is material to the question of whether or not the application is granted;
(b)
if made without notice, state why no notice has been given.
(8)
The court may vary or discharge an interim enforcement order on the application of the applicant or the respondent.
(9)
An interim enforcement order made in respect of conduct of the respondent is discharged—
(a)
on the determination of an application for an enforcement order made against the respondent in respect of that conduct, or
(b)
on the giving of a final infringement notice to the respondent in respect of that conduct.
Online interface orders and interim online interface orders
160Applications
(1)
A public designated enforcer may apply to the appropriate court for an online interface order, or an interim online interface order, if the enforcer considers that a person has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice that constitutes a relevant infringement.
(2)
An application for an online interface order, or an interim online interface order, may be made in respect of—
(a)
the person that the enforcer considers has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice that constitutes a relevant infringement, or
(b)
any other person (subject to subsection (3)).
(3)
An application under subsection (2)(b) in respect of a person who is outside the United Kingdom may be made only if the person—
(a)
is a United Kingdom national,
(b)
is an individual who is habitually resident in the United Kingdom,
(c)
is a firm established in the United Kingdom, or
(d)
carries on business in the United Kingdom or by any means directs activities in the course of carrying on a business to consumers in the United Kingdom.
(4)
For the purposes of subsection (3)(c), a firm is “established in the United Kingdom” if—
(a)
it is incorporated or formed under the law of a part of the United Kingdom, or
(b)
it is administered under arrangements governed by the law of a part of the United Kingdom.
(5)
Section 154 (CMA directions to other enforcers) applies where it appears to the CMA that another public designated enforcer intends to make an application for an online interface order, or an interim online interface order, as it applies in relation to intended applications for enforcement orders and interim enforcement orders, but for this purpose the reference to such other enforcer in subsection (2)(b) is to be taken as a reference only to such other public designated enforcer.
(6)
Nothing in this section or in section 161 or 162 limits other powers under this Chapter to make enforcement orders or interim enforcement orders or to accept undertakings.
161Online interface orders
(1)
The court may make an online interface order on an application under section 160 if the court finds that—
(a)
a person has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice that constitutes a relevant infringement,
(b)
there are no other available means under this Chapter of bringing about the cessation or prohibition of the infringement which, by themselves, would be wholly effective, and
(c)
it is necessary to make the order to avoid the risk of serious harm to the collective interests of consumers.
(2)
An online interface order is an order that directs the person against whom it is made to do, or to co-operate with another person so that person can do, one or more of the following—
(a)
remove content from, or modify content on, an online interface;
(b)
disable or restrict access to an online interface;
(c)
display a warning to consumers accessing an online interface;
(d)
delete a fully qualified domain name and take any steps necessary to facilitate the registration of that domain name by the public designated enforcer that applied for the order.
(3)
Where an online interface order is made, the public designated enforcer that applied for the order may publish—
(a)
the order, and
(b)
where known, the identity of the person who has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice which constitutes the relevant infringement.
(4)
Publication under subsection (3) is to be made in such form and manner as the enforcer considers appropriate for the purpose of eliminating any continuing effects of the relevant infringement.
(5)
In subsection (2) “online interface” means any software, including a website, part of a website, an application or other digital content which—
(a)
is operated by a person (“P”) acting for purposes relating to P’s business or by a person acting in the name of, or on behalf of, P, and
(b)
is operated for or in connection with the purposes of giving access to, or promoting, goods, services or digital content that P or another person supplies.
162Interim online interface orders
(1)
The court may make an interim online interface order against a person (“the respondent”) on an application under section 160 if—
(a)
it is alleged that there has been or is likely to be a relevant infringement,
(b)
it appears to the court that if the application had been an application for an online interface order it would be likely to be granted, and
(c)
the court considers it expedient to bring about the cessation or prohibition of the infringement immediately.
(2)
If no notice of the application has been given to the respondent—
(a)
the application must state why no notice has been given, and
(b)
the court may make the order only if it considers it appropriate for the order to be made without notice.
(3)
An interim online interface order is an order that directs the respondent to do, or to co-operate with another person so that person can do, one or more of the following—
(a)
remove content from, or modify content on, an online interface;
(b)
disable or restrict access to an online interface;
(c)
display a warning to consumers accessing an online interface;
(d)
delete a fully qualified domain name and take any steps necessary to facilitate the registration of that domain name by the public designated enforcer that applied for the order.
In this subsection “online interface” has the meaning given by section 161(5).
(4)
An application for an interim online interface order against the respondent may not be made at any time after—
(a)
an application for an online interface order against the respondent in respect of the same relevant infringement is determined, or
(b)
an online interface notice in respect of the same relevant infringement has been given to the respondent (see section 184).
(5)
An application for an interim online interface order must include all information known to the public designated enforcer making the application that is material to the question of whether or not the application is granted.
(6)
The court may vary or discharge an interim online interface order on the application of the enforcer that applied for the order or the respondent.
(7)
An interim online interface order against the respondent is discharged on the determination of—
(a)
an application for an online interface order made against the respondent in respect of the same relevant infringement, or
(b)
an online interface notice in respect of the same relevant infringement has been given to the respondent.
Undertakings and further proceedings
163Acceptance of undertakings by enforcers
(1)
This section applies where an enforcer could make an application under section 153 for an enforcement order, or an interim enforcement order, against a person (“the respondent”) whom the enforcer believes—
(a)
has engaged, is engaging or is likely to engage in a commercial practice which constitutes a relevant infringement (“the infringing practice”), or
(b)
is an accessory to the infringing practice.
(2)
The enforcer may accept an undertaking from the respondent to do one or more of the following—
(a)
in the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(a), not to continue or repeat the infringing practice (where it is alleged that the respondent has engaged or is engaging in that practice);
(b)
in the case of a respondent within subsection (1)(b), not to consent to or connive in the infringing practice;
(c)
in either case, not to engage in the infringing practice in the course of the respondent’s business or another business;
(d)
in either case, not to consent to or connive in the carrying out of the infringing practice by a body corporate with which the respondent has a special relationship (see section 220).
(3)
See also section 164 about the inclusion of enhanced consumer measures in an undertaking under this section.
(4)
Where the enforcer accepts an undertaking under subsection (2) the enforcer may publish the undertaking or accept a further undertaking from the respondent to do so.
(5)
Publication under subsection (4)—
(a)
must be made in such form and manner, and to such an extent, as the enforcer considers appropriate for the purpose of eliminating any continuing effects of the infringing practice;
(b)
is not an enhanced consumer measure for the purposes of this Chapter.
(6)
Where an enforcer has accepted from the respondent an undertaking under this section—
(a)
the enforcer may accept from the respondent any such variation of the undertaking that the enforcer considers appropriate for meeting the purposes for which the undertaking was given;
(b)
the enforcer may release the respondent from the undertaking (whether on its own initiative or at the respondent’s request) if the enforcer considers that the undertaking is no longer necessary to meet those purposes.
(7)
Each enforcer must keep a record of—
(a)
undertakings it has accepted under this section, and
(b)
reviews it has carried out into the effectiveness of such undertakings.
(8)
In determining for the purposes of subsection (1) whether an enforcer could make an application under section 153, section 169 is to be ignored.
164Undertakings under section 163: enhanced consumer measures
(1)
An undertaking under section 163(2) may include a requirement to take such enhanced consumer measures as the enforcer accepting the undertaking considers just and reasonable.
(2)
For this purpose, the enforcer must in particular consider whether any proposed enhanced consumer measures are proportionate having regard to—
(a)
the likely benefit of the measures to consumers,
(b)
the costs likely to be incurred by the respondent, and
(c)
the likely cost to consumers of obtaining the benefit of the measures.
(3)
The costs referred to in subsection (2)(b) are—
(a)
the cost of the measures, and
(b)
the reasonable administrative costs associated with taking the measures.
(4)
Where the respondent is required by an undertaking to take enhanced consumer measures, the undertaking may include requirements for the respondent to provide information or documents to the enforcer accepting the undertaking in order that the enforcer may determine if the respondent is taking those measures.
(5)
Subsection (6) applies if—
(a)
an undertaking under section 163(2) includes enhanced consumer measures offering compensation, and
(b)
a settlement agreement is entered into in connection with the payment of compensation.
(6)
A waiver of a person’s rights in the settlement agreement is not valid if it is a waiver of the right to bring civil proceedings in respect of conduct other than conduct which has given rise to the undertaking.
(7)
This section is subject to section 177 (private designated enforcers).
165Undertakings under section 163: procedural requirements
(1)
This section applies where an enforcer proposes to—
(a)
accept a material variation of an undertaking under section 163, or
(b)
release the respondent from any such undertaking,
and the proposed variation or release has not been requested by the respondent.
(2)
Before taking the proposed action mentioned in subsection (1) the enforcer must—
(a)
give notice to the respondent under subsection (3), and
(b)
consider any representations made in accordance with the notice.
(3)
A notice under this subsection must state—
(a)
the fact that the enforcer is proposing to act as mentioned in subsection (1),
(b)
the reasons for doing so, and
(c)
the means by which, and the time by which, representations may be made in relation to the proposed action.
(4)
If after considering any representations made in accordance with a notice under subsection (3) an enforcer decides to take an action mentioned in subsection (1), the enforcer must give notice to the respondent of that decision.
(5)
The reference in subsection (1)(a) to a material variation is a reference to any variation that the enforcer considers to be material in any respect.
166Consumer protection orders or undertakings to court: further proceedings
(1)
This section applies if the court—
(a)
makes a consumer protection order against a person (“the respondent”) on an application made by an enforcer (“the original application”), or
(b)
accepts an undertaking from the respondent under section 156 or 159 on the making of the original application.
(2)
References in this Part to a “consumer protection order” are references to—
(a)
an enforcement order,
(b)
an interim enforcement order,
(c)
an online interface order, or
(d)
an interim online interface order.
(3)
An application may (subject to subsection (7)) be made to the same court to which the original application was made in respect of a failure to comply with the order or undertaking in question—
(a)
by the enforcer that made the original application, or
(b)
by any other enforcer other than a private designated enforcer.
(4)
An application to the court in respect of a failure to comply with an undertaking may include an application for a consumer protection order of any kind that the enforcer concerned is authorised under this Chapter to apply for.
(5)
If on an application under this section the court finds that an undertaking is not being complied with, the court may do either or both of the following—
(a)
make a consumer protection order (instead of making any other order it has power to make);
(b)
make an order requiring the respondent to pay a monetary penalty.
(6)
Where an application is made under subsection (4) for a consumer protection order—
(b)
the application may be made only in respect of a commercial practice that the enforcer considers a person has engaged or is engaging in (and not in respect of a practice that a person is likely to engage in);
(c)
a power of the court to accept an undertaking instead of making a consumer protection order does not apply,
and the preceding provisions of this Chapter apply subject to this subsection.
(7)
An application may not be made under subsection (3) in the case of a failure to comply with an order or undertaking which consists only of a failure to provide information or documents required by the order or undertaking under section 157(4).
(8)
In addition to any right of appeal on a point of law, a person liable to pay a penalty by virtue of an order under subsection (5)(b) may appeal in respect of—
(a)
the decision to impose the penalty, or
(b)
the nature or amount of the penalty.
(9)
In connection with orders under subsection (5)(b), see further—
(a)
section 168, which provides for the amount of penalties, and
(b)
section 203, which provides for information to accompany such orders.
167Undertakings to public designated enforcers: further proceedings
(1)
This section applies where a public designated enforcer accepts an undertaking from a person (“the respondent”) under section 163.
(2)
The enforcer may apply to the court in respect of a failure to comply with the undertaking.
(3)
An application under subsection (2) may include an application for a consumer protection order of any kind that the enforcer concerned is authorised under this Chapter to apply for.
(4)
If the court finds that the undertaking is not being complied with, the court may do either or both of the following—
(a)
make a consumer protection order (instead of making any other order it has power to make);
(b)
make an order requiring the respondent to pay a monetary penalty.
(5)
A requirement under subsection (4)(b) to pay a monetary penalty may be imposed only if the court is satisfied that the respondent’s failure in question is without reasonable excuse.
(6)
Where an application is made under subsection (2) for a consumer protection order—
(b)
the application may be made only in respect of a commercial practice that the enforcer considers a person has engaged or is engaging in (and not in respect of a practice that a person is likely to engage in);
(c)
a power of the court to accept an undertaking instead of making a consumer protection order does not apply,
and the preceding provisions of this Chapter apply subject to this subsection.
(7)
An application may not be made under subsection (2) in the case of a failure to comply with an undertaking which consists only of a failure to provide information or documents under section 164(4).
(8)
In addition to any right of appeal on a point of law, a person liable to pay a penalty by virtue of an order under subsection (4)(b) may appeal in respect of—
(a)
the decision to impose the penalty, or
(b)
the nature or amount of the penalty.
(9)
In connection with orders under subsection (4)(b), see further—
(a)
section 168, which provides for the amount of penalties, and
(b)
section 203, which provides for information to accompany such orders.
168Monetary penalties under sections 166 and 167: amount
(1)
This section applies in relation to a monetary penalty imposed on a person (“the respondent”) by an order made under section 166 or 167.
(2)
The amount of the penalty must be—
(a)
a fixed amount,
(b)
an amount calculated by reference to a daily rate, or
(c)
a combination of a fixed amount and an amount calculated by reference to a daily rate.
(3)
The penalty must not exceed—
(a)
in the case of a fixed amount, £150,000 or, if higher, 5% of the total value of the turnover (if any) of the respondent;
(b)
in the case of an amount calculated by reference to a daily rate, for each day £15,000 or, if higher, 5% of the total value of the daily turnover (if any) of the respondent;
(c)
in the case of a fixed amount and an amount calculated by reference to a daily rate, such fixed amount and such amount per day.
(4)
In imposing a penalty by reference to a daily rate—
(a)
no account is to be taken of any days before notice of the application under section 166(3) or 167(2) was given to the respondent, and
(b)
unless the court determines an earlier date, the amount payable ceases to accumulate on the day on which the requirements of the undertaking that the respondent has failed to comply with are complied with.
Notification of CMA
169Notification requirements: applications
(1)
This section applies to an enforcer that is not the CMA.
(2)
Before making an application for a consumer protection order the enforcer—
(a)
must by notice inform the CMA of its intention to do so, and
(b)
may only proceed to make the application after expiry of the minimum period or, if sooner, after the CMA has by notice informed the enforcer that it consents to the making of the application.
(3)
The “minimum period” is—
(a)
in the case of an enforcement order or an online interface order, 14 days beginning with the day on which the notice under subsection (2)(a) is given;
(b)
in the case of an interim enforcement order or an interim online interface order, 7 days beginning with the day on which the notice under subsection (2)(a) is given.
(4)
Where an enforcer proceeds to make an application for a consumer protection order, the enforcer must by notice inform the CMA of the result of the application.
(5)
Subsection (6) applies where the enforcer makes an application under section 166 in respect of a failure to comply with—
(a)
a consumer protection order, or
(b)
an undertaking given under section 156 or 159.
(6)
The enforcer must by notice inform the CMA of the making of the application and of any order made by the court on the application.
170Notification requirements: undertakings
(1)
This section applies to an enforcer that is not the CMA which accepts an undertaking under section 163.
(2)
The enforcer must by notice inform the CMA of—
(a)
the terms of the undertaking, and
(b)
the identity of the person who gave it.
171Notification requirements: proceedings
(1)
This section applies where a local weights and measures authority in England and Wales intends to start proceedings for an offence under an enactment listed in Part 1 of Schedule 15.
(2)
Before starting the proceedings the authority—
(a)
must by notice inform the CMA of its intention to do so, and
(b)
may only start the proceedings on or after the relevant day.
(3)
The “relevant day” is—
(a)
the day on which the CMA notifies the authority that the CMA has received the authority’s notice given under subsection (2)(a), or
(b)
if sooner, the day beginning 14 days after the day on which that notice was given.
(4)
Where the authority starts the proceedings, the authority must by notice inform the CMA of outcome of the proceedings.
(5)
A failure of an authority to comply with a requirement under this section does not invalidate any proceedings started by the authority.
172Notification requirements: convictions and judgments
(1)
This section applies where—
(a)
a person is convicted of an offence by or before a court in the United Kingdom, or
(b)
a judgment is given against a person by a court in civil proceedings in the United Kingdom.
(2)
The court may make arrangements to bring the conviction or judgment to the attention of the CMA if it appears to the court—
(a)
having regard to the functions of the CMA under this Chapter or Chapter 4, that it is expedient for the conviction or judgment to be brought to the attention of the CMA, and
(b)
without such arrangements the conviction or judgment may not be brought to the attention of the CMA.
(3)
For the purposes of subsection (2) it is immaterial whether the proceedings have been finally disposed of by the court.
(4)
Judgment includes an order or decree (and references to the giving of a judgment are to be construed accordingly).
Jurisdiction etc
173Appropriate court
(1)
This section applies for the purposes of determining the appropriate court in relation to an application for, or the making of, a consumer protection order against a person (“the respondent”) in connection with a relevant infringement.
(2)
If the respondent has a place of business in, or carries on business in, a part of the United Kingdom, the appropriate court is—
(a)
the High Court or the county court in England and Wales, if the respondent carries on business in England and Wales or has a place of business in England and Wales;
(b)
the High Court or a county court in Northern Ireland, if the respondent carries on business in Northern Ireland or has a place of business in Northern Ireland;
(c)
the Court of Session or the sheriff, if the respondent carries on business in Scotland or has a place of business in Scotland.
(3)
If the respondent does not have a place of business in, and does not carry on business in, any part of the United Kingdom, the appropriate court is—
(a)
the High Court or the county court in England and Wales, if a relevant consumer is domiciled in England or Wales;
(b)
the High Court or a county court in Northern Ireland, if a relevant consumer is domiciled in Northern Ireland;
(c)
the Court of Session or the sheriff, if a relevant consumer is domiciled in Scotland.
(4)
References in subsection (3) to a “relevant consumer” are to any consumer—
(a)
to or for whom goods, services or digital content are supplied in connection with which the relevant infringement has, or is alleged to have, taken place,
(b)
to whom activities are directed the carrying out of which constitutes, or is alleged to constitute, the relevant infringement, or
(c)
from whom goods are received in connection with which the relevant infringement has, or is alleged to have, taken place.
(5)
Section 41 of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982 applies for the purposes of determining the part of the United Kingdom in which a relevant consumer is domiciled.
174Effect of orders in other parts of the United Kingdom
A consumer protection order made in a part of the United Kingdom by a court specified in relation to that part in the second or third column of the Table has effect in another part of the United Kingdom as if made by a court specified in relation to that other part in the same column of the Table—
|
England and Wales |
The High Court |
The county court |
|
Scotland |
The Court of Session |
The sheriff |
|
Northern Ireland |
The High Court |
A county court. |
175Evidence
(1)
Proceedings under this Chapter are civil proceedings for the purposes of—
(a)
section 11 of the Civil Evidence Act 1968 (convictions admissible as evidence in civil proceedings);
(b)
section 10 of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) (Scotland) Act 1968 (corresponding provision in Scotland);
(c)
section 7 of the Civil Evidence Act (Northern Ireland) 1971 (c.36 (N.I.)) (corresponding provision in Northern Ireland).
(2)
In proceedings under this Chapter any finding by a court in civil proceedings that a person has engaged in infringing conduct—
(a)
is admissible as evidence that the conduct has occurred;
(b)
unless the contrary is proved, is sufficient evidence that the conduct has occurred.
(3)
But subsection (2) does not apply to any finding—
(a)
which has been reversed on appeal;
(b)
which has been varied on appeal so as to negate it.
(4)
For the purposes of subsection (2), a person engages in “infringing conduct” if—
(a)
the person has engaged in a commercial practice that constitutes a relevant infringement, or
(b)
the person is an accessory to such a practice.
Miscellaneous
176Interconnected bodies corporate
(1)
This section applies if—
(a)
a court makes a consumer protection order against a body corporate (“the respondent”), and
(b)
the interconnection condition applies in relation to the respondent.
(2)
The interconnection condition applies in relation to the respondent if—
(a)
at the time the order is made the respondent is a member of a group of interconnected bodies corporate,
(b)
at any time when the order is in force the respondent becomes a member of a group of interconnected bodies corporate, or
(c)
at any time when the order is in force a group of interconnected bodies corporate of which the respondent is a member is increased by the addition of one or more further members.
(3)
The order may include provision for the requirements (or any particular requirements) imposed by the order to be binding upon all other members of the group (in addition to the respondent) as if each of them were the respondent.
(4)
Provision may be included in an order under subsection (3) only if the court considers it just, reasonable and proportionate to include that provision.
(5)
A group of interconnected bodies corporate is a group consisting of two or more bodies corporate all of whom are interconnected with each other.
(6)
Any two bodies corporate are interconnected—
(a)
if one of them is a subsidiary of the other, or
(b)
if both of them are subsidiaries of the same body corporate.
(7)
Where an order includes provision under subsection (3), a copy of the order must be given to any other member of the respondent’s group in relation to which the requirements imposed by the order are to be binding.
177Enhanced consumer measures: private designated enforcers
(1)
This section applies where—
(a)
an enforcement order is made on the application of a private designated enforcer,
(b)
an undertaking is given under section 156 on an application for an enforcement order made by a private designated enforcer, or
(c)
an undertaking is given under section 163 to a private designated enforcer.
(2)
The enforcement order or undertaking may include a requirement for the taking of any enhanced consumer measures only if both of the following conditions are met.
(3)
The first condition is that the private designated enforcer is specified for the purposes of this section in regulations made by the Secretary of State.
(4)
The second condition is that the enhanced consumer measures do not directly benefit the private designated enforcer or an associated undertaking.
(5)
Enhanced consumer measures directly benefiting an enforcer or an associated undertaking include (for example) measures which—
(a)
require a person to pay money to the enforcer or an associated undertaking;
(b)
require a person to participate in a scheme, administered by the enforcer or associated undertaking, that is designed to recommend persons supplying goods, services or digital content to consumers;
(c)
would give the enforcer or associated undertaking a commercial advantage over any of its competitors.
(6)
An enforcer may be specified in regulations under subsection (3) only if—
(a)
the functions of the enforcer under this Chapter have been specified under section 24 of the Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006 (functions to which principles under section 21 and code of practice under section 22 apply), so far as capable of being so specified, and
(b)
the Secretary of State is satisfied that to do so is likely to—
(i)
improve the availability to consumers of redress for relevant infringements,
(ii)
improve the availability to consumers of information which enables them to choose more effectively between persons supplying goods, services or digital content, or
(iii)
improve compliance with consumer law.
(7)
Subsection (8) applies if—
(a)
an enforcer exercises a function in relation to a person by virtue of this section,
(b)
the function is a relevant function for the purposes of Part 2 of the Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Act 2008 (co-ordination of regulatory enforcement), and
(c)
a primary authority (within the meaning of that Part) has given advice or guidance under section 24A(1) or (2) of that Act—
(i)
to that person in relation to the function, or
(ii)
to other local authorities (within the meaning of that Part) with that function as to how they should exercise it in relation to that person.
(8)
The enforcer must have regard to the advice or guidance in exercising the function in relation to that person.
(9)
Regulations under this section are subject to the negative procedure.
(10)
In this section “associated undertaking”, in relation to a private designated enforcer, means—
(a)
a parent undertaking or subsidiary undertaking of the enforcer, or
(b)
a subsidiary undertaking of a parent undertaking of the enforcer,
and for this purpose “parent undertaking” and “subsidiary undertaking” have the meanings given by section 1162 of the Companies Act 2006.
178Substantiation of claims
(1)
This section applies where an application for a consumer protection order is made to a court in respect of a relevant infringement involving a contravention of Chapter 1 of Part 4 (protection from unfair trading).
(2)
The court may, for the purpose of considering the application, require a respondent to provide evidence as to the accuracy of any factual claim made as part of a commercial practice of the respondent.
(3)
The court may find that a factual claim of a respondent is inaccurate if—
(a)
the respondent fails to provide evidence of the accuracy of the claim in response to a requirement imposed under subsection (2), or
(b)
the court considers that any such evidence that is provided is inadequate.
(4)
In this section “respondent”, in relation to an application for a consumer protection order, means—
(a)
where the application is for an enforcement order or an interim enforcement order, the person against whom the order is sought;
(b)
where the application is for an online interface order or an interim online interface order, the person against whom the order is sought or another person who is a party to the proceedings.
179Crown application
(1)
Subject to subsection (2), this Chapter binds the Crown.
(2)
The Crown is not liable for any monetary penalty imposed by virtue of this Chapter.