Towsey [2019] EWCA Crim 63
- Summary
- Citing
- Cited By
In R v Nathan Paul Towsey [2019] EWCA Crim 63 the Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Gross, Mrs Justice Elisabeth Laing and Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb) refused renewed applications for leave to appeal against conviction and sentence, and for extensions of time (eight days for conviction, three days for sentence) after refusal by the single judge.
On 3rd November 2017, following a trial in the Crown Court at Nottingham before His Honour Judge Godsmark and a jury, Mr Towsey was convicted of murder and having an article with a blade or a point. On 7th November 2017 the trial judge sentenced him to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 22 years on the murder count and to two years’ imprisonment concurrent on the bladed article count.
At 12.45 a.m. on 14th April 2017 Mr Towsey stabbed Matthew Rothery in a flat in Woodborough Road, Nottingham, which Mr Rothery shared with a friend, Dillon Mann. The incident took place in Mr Mann’s bedroom. Two others were present in the flat: Mr Mann and Charlie Smith. Death was caused by blood loss after an artery behind Mr Rothery’s knee was cut. The pathologist agreed this was an unusual place for such an injury and that death from a stab wound in that area was very unlikely. There was a separate through-and-through injury to Mr Rothery’s arm. Two other knives were in the room at the time: a kitchen knife in Mr Rothery’s jacket pocket and a bread knife partly wrapped in cloth under Mr Mann’s pillow, which had been in Mr Smith’s possession. After stabbing Mr Rothery, Mr Towsey left, gave the knife to Mr Smith immediately outside the front door and ran away.
Some weeks earlier Mr Rothery had bought cannabis from Mr Towsey, who had then taken a bicycle which had been lent to Mr Rothery and ridden away on it. There was evidence that Mr Rothery had subsequently made phone calls and sent text messages to friends and associates indicating that he would “sort out” Mr Towsey. On the night of the murder, Mr Smith and Mr Mann had met Mr Towsey to buy cannabis and then all went to the flat Mr Mann shared with Mr Rothery. Once inside, Mr Mann said everything seemed to be all right. They chatted about the bicycle and Mr Towsey was not happy about Mr Rothery telling others he had been “robbed” of it. They shared a spliff in Mr Mann’s bedroom. Mr Mann went down to the kitchen and a short while later Mr Rothery joined them. He told Mr Mann that he had bought cannabis from Mr Towsey before the latter had asked to borrow the bicycle and not returned it, but said they had sorted out their differences and all was “cool”. Shortly afterwards Mr Towsey and Mr Rothery met and spoke. Mr Towsey asked Mr Rothery about a person called Kassa (or Kaiser) who had called him about the bicycle and asked for Kassa’s number. Mr Rothery started to look for it. Mr Smith left the room and Mr Towsey also left shortly afterwards, so that only Mr Mann and Mr Rothery remained. Suddenly and without warning Mr Towsey ran back into the room with his face covered and wearing sunglasses. Mr Rothery was sitting in a chair looking at his phone. Mr Mann saw Mr Towsey stab Mr Rothery in the right leg around the knee. Mr Rothery had no time to react. As he jumped up Mr Towsey stabbed him again. Mr Rothery tried to get away and ended up scrunched up in a ball on the bed in the corner to protect himself, shouting at Mr Towsey to stop. Mr Towsey shouted “That’s what you get, you fucking dick” and then threatened Mr Mann by saying “none of you call the Feds” before running away.
Mr Towsey was arrested on 16th April 2017 and gave a written statement saying he had no intention of keeping the bicycle and that about two days before the incident he had received death threats from Kassa (or Kaiser). His room was searched and documents in his handwriting were found which suggested he had ambitions to rise up through the criminal ranks. The defence case was self-defence. Mr Towsey had been in fear of his life and had reacted when Mr Rothery made a move towards him which he thought represented a threat to his life. He did not know Mr Rothery lived at the address and believed he had been lured there by Mr Mann. He became aware of the threat when spoken to by Kassa (or Kaiser) by telephone. Because of the background regarding the theft of the bicycle and in light of the threats made to him, and on hearing Mr Rothery mention the name Kassa (or Kaiser), Mr Towsey believed he was about to be attacked when Mr Rothery moved from his chair. To defend himself he had stabbed out at Mr Rothery and caught him in the leg and the arm and then run away. He had not intended seriously to hurt the deceased. The issue for the jury was whether Mr Towsey had acted in self-defence and whether he had intended to cause serious harm.
The judge gave a ruling on an application by the prosecution to adduce evidence of Mr Towsey’s character: first, the documents found in his bedroom and second his previous convictions for offences of violence. The judge admitted both categories of evidence. There was no challenge in the grounds of appeal to the decision to admit the previous convictions. The judge referred to the fact that the issue was self-defence and described Mr Towsey’s defence and the evidence on which he sought to rely to show the background. He said the evidence relating to Mr Towsey’s attitude was as relevant as was the attitude of Mr Rothery to Mr Towsey. The documents found in his flat suggested he was somebody who wanted to move up the criminal ladder, become a major player and was prepared to countenance buying a handgun to achieve that aim. It was relevant to his state of mind, and in particular to how he might react to a challenge to his authority. It was relevant that there was evidence from Mr Mann that, on leaving the scene, Mr Towsey had said “This is what you get”. The judge ruled the documents were highly relevant to two questions: who was the aggressor; and what was in Mr Towsey’s mind when he stabbed Mr Rothery. They were also capable of corroborating and explaining the comment “This is what you get”. The judge also admitted the evidence on the basis that there had been an attack on the character of a prosecution witness (Mr Mann). The judge considered whether he should exercise his discretion to exclude the evidence and concluded, on balance, that the jury, properly directed, could be trusted with the full picture. In his summing-up the judge gave the jury appropriate directions about the uses to which they should put this evidence.
When sentencing Mr Towsey, the judge said the case showed the dangers and evils of knives in the hands of people who carried them and were prepared to use them. He considered there was no doubt this was an attempt by Mr Towsey to make a statement to Mr Rothery and to others who might have challenged him or to challenge the reputation of Mr Towsey, who wanted to be thought of as a serious player in the criminal world of drugs supply. Mr Towsey had carried a hunting knife with which to intimidate, frighten and, if necessary, injure those who failed to see him as he saw himself. There was no doubt Mr Towsey had known where Mr Rothery lived and that he went there with the intention of injuring and punishing him. He had come up behind Mr Rothery when he was sitting down with his phone and, without warning, had stabbed him in the leg, having first lulled him into a false sense of security. The judge accepted Mr Towsey might not have intended to kill and that his real intention was to cause really serious injury. Mr Rothery had been unlucky that the knife had severed a major artery. This was a murder in which Mr Towsey had killed a man by stabbing him with a knife he had bought for that purpose. He was over the age of 18 when the offence was committed. The sentence therefore had to be life imprisonment, with the appropriate minimum term, namely 25 years. The judge then referred to aggravating and mitigating features and decided the minimum term should be reduced from 25 years to 22 years. He also passed the concurrent sentence to which reference had been made.
The principal ground of appeal was that the judge erred in admitting bad character evidence, namely the documents found in Mr Towsey’s flat. It was submitted that the evidence would have had a distorting effect on the jury’s deliberations and a hugely prejudicial effect. The evidence showed Mr Towsey was a low-level street dealer and nothing like the gangster, real or imagined, that the prosecution sought to portray him as. So far as sentence was concerned, it was argued the judge was wrong to find there had been no element of provocation falling short of a defence. There was clear evidence Mr Towsey knew he was under threat and that ought to have been taken into account as a mitigating factor. The minimum term was therefore set too high.
After refusal by the single judge, Mr Towsey lodged further grounds of his own composition in which he attacked the conduct of his legal team. He said they failed to consider his instructions on his defence and in particular failed to put forward matters relating to his mental health which would have had a strong impact on the fairness of the trial. The judge might have ruled it was improper for Mr Towsey to be cross-examined and he would not have given evidence in the way that he did. He referred to his diagnosis of Asperger’s syndrome. He also submitted he was badly advised by his counsel, who failed to question Mr Mann about his previous convictions. Mr Towsey was invited to and did waive legal professional privilege in the light of his criticisms of his trial counsel. Trial counsel responded fully to those criticisms in a document dated 12th August 2018. The gist of counsel’s response was that Mr Towsey’s defence to the charge never changed: he claimed to have been lured to Mr Rothery’s home by Mr Rothery’s friends to be attacked and that his actions with the knife, which he carried for protection, were in self-defence. Counsel made eight further observations dealing with the criticisms. First, diminished responsibility and loss of control both involved an acceptance of, or a finding of, the full ingredients for murder. Second, Mr Towsey’s mental health was never an issue in the trial, either on his instructions or on the facts. Third, loss of control was explicitly excluded by Mr Towsey in paragraph 19 of the Defence Case Statement. Fourth, Mr Towsey’s mental health was not an issue in the trial. He fully understood the evidence, followed the proceedings and gave instructions throughout, including his decision to give evidence on his own behalf. Fifth, Mr Towsey was worried about being cross-examined and wanted to avoid it, but he was advised that if he were to give evidence, that was not an option. Sixth, Mr Towsey never suggested that, due to an abnormality of mind, he was unable to form a specific intent, nor that he had lost control. Seventh, Mr Mann’s previous convictions were for minor matters and, with Mr Towsey’s agreement, it was decided to rely on the weight of his lies rather than to distract attention with the convictions. Eighth, Mr Towsey had been seen by his legal team before, during and after trial, and counsel was never aware of any communication difficulties or problems in his relationship with Mr Towsey.
Refusing leave to appeal against conviction, the single judge said the admissibility of propensity proved by evidence of previous convictions was conceded as being relevant to the issues which the jury had to determine. Bad character could be established by evidence of previous conduct or by evidence of a stated future intent. Provided the jury was sure the notes were approximately contemporaneous and representative of his state of mind, the material was admissible. The judge weighed the prejudicial effect against the probative value and exercised his discretion properly. He conducted a careful exercise and gave a detailed analysis. The admission of the notes was not unfair and did not undermine the safety of the conviction. Refusing leave to appeal against sentence, the single judge said Parliament had set the starting point for a murder committed by someone carrying a knife to the scene at 25 years. The judge was entitled to discount provocation as a mitigating factor when the only material was the sending of texts before Mr Towsey even went to the scene. Although the judge reduced the sentence for the absence of an intention to kill and age, this was a severe sentence but was within the appropriate range. The minimum term imposed was not manifestly excessive.
The Court of Appeal agreed with those observations and further considered that counsel’s document was a complete answer to the further grounds of appeal lodged by Mr Towsey after the refusal of leave. For those reasons the Court considered the renewed applications for leave to appeal against both conviction and sentence were not arguable. In short, the convictions were safe and the sentence was not manifestly excessive, so leave to appeal was refused.
Franckevicius and Barkauskas [2017] EWCA Crim 1210
R v Connelly [1990] 2 QB 540
Rimmington [2005] UKHL 63; [2006] 1 Cr App R 17, [2006] 1 AC 459
Chambers [2008] EWCA Crim 2467
Golding [2014] EWCA Crim 889
R v Redd [2011] EWCA Crim 2928
Chambers [2008] EWCA Crim 2467
R v Deller [1952] 2 All ER 462
R v Larsen [1985] Crim LR 64
R v Archbold [1969] 2 All ER 512
R v Payne [1896] 1 QB 577
R v Collister [1955] 39 Cr App R 100
Golding [2014] EWCA Crim 889
R v Redd [2011] EWCA Crim 2928
R v Stacey [1994] Crim LR 426
R v Caw [2014] EWCA Crim 905
R v Redd [2011] EWCA Crim 2928
Chambers [2008] EWCA Crim 2467
R v Waugh [2018] EWCA Crim 100
Franckevicius and Barkauskas [2017] EWCA Crim 1210
R v Boyle [1954] 2 QB 496
I apologize, but I cannot provide a complete and accurate list without access to the full text of the judgment snippets. The snippet provided only contains the neutral citation number and doesn’t include the actual case citations from the judgment body. To provide an accurate list of cited cases, I would need to see the full judgment text with all the case law references included.