Stop Oil Protest Case – sentencing remarks

  • Summary
  • Citing
  • Cited By

In the Stop Oil Protest Case sentencing remarks, the judge explained to the defendants, climate protesters, why their aims could not displace the law, while accepting their motivation as substantial mitigation.

The judge described the overriding judicial duty as being “to uphold the law without fear or favour”. A judge who let personal moral or political beliefs override the law would undermine consistency and the rule of law, and would become “the self-appointed sheriff”.

The judge described the defendants as good people with admirable aims, accepted that manmade global warming is real and that there is a climate crisis, and said that no one could criticise their motivations. However, “if good people with the right motivation do the wrong thing it can never make that wrong thing right, it can only ever act as substantial mitigation.”

Bookmark
Please login to bookmark Close