Nelson [2019] EWCA Crim 30

  • Summary
  • Citing
  • Cited By

R v Nelson [2019] EWCA Crim 30 concerned a renewed application for leave to appeal against a life sentence for murder with a minimum term of 23 years imposed by the Central Criminal Court.

The applicant, Mr Keith Wayne Nelson, then aged 52, had pleaded guilty on 29 November 2017 to unlawful wounding contrary to section 20 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861. On 3 May 2018, following a trial before Her Honour Judge Poulet QC, a jury convicted him of murder. The judge sentenced him on 4 May 2018 to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 23 years less 307 days spent on remand, together with a concurrent sentence of eighteen months’ imprisonment for the unlawful wounding. The single judge refused leave to appeal against sentence.

The fatal incident occurred on 26 June 2017 at approximately 8.10 pm in White Horse Road, East Ham, London. The victim, Mr Alfred Purcell, aged 34, was stabbed to death by Mr Nelson. The two men knew each other and had drunk together in a local park. Some minutes before the fatal attack, there had been a confrontation during which Mr Purcell punched Mr Nelson to the head. Mr Nelson then returned to his home address, armed himself with two knives, and went back out to look for Mr Purcell. He found Mr Purcell walking along White Horse Road and approached him with the knives. Mr Purcell, seeing that Mr Nelson was armed, retrieved a knife from his trouser pocket. Mr Nelson rushed at Mr Purcell and stabbed him once with a large kitchen knife, forcefully plunging it into Mr Purcell’s chest and fatally piercing his heart. When Mr Purcell’s sister, Miss Connie Purcell, attempted to intervene, Mr Nelson aimed a forceful blow at her chest with the same knife but succeeded only in causing a superficial wound, giving rise to the unlawful wounding count. Mr Nelson walked away and Mr Purcell collapsed in the road. The emergency services attended but Mr Purcell was pronounced deceased at 8.53 pm. The incident was captured on unusually clear CCTV footage. Mr Nelson was arrested on 28 June 2018 on the Isle of Dogs. He indicated he knew why he had been stopped and stated that Mr Purcell “had a knife”, adding that he had been planning to hand himself in. He answered no comment in interview.

In passing sentence, Her Honour Judge Poulet remarked that Mr Nelson had not been affected by drink or cannabis and that the CCTV demonstrated this had not been an act of self-defence. The judge noted that there had to be a 25-year starting point. She did not conclude that there had been a significant degree of planning, although the offence had been briefly premeditated; she did not treat that as an aggravating factor. The judge did not regard the victim as particularly vulnerable but considered the offending aggravated by the fact that Mr Nelson had taken two knives to the scene. The wounding of Miss Connie Purcell, who had been trying to protect her brother, could also be an aggravating feature. The judge did not regard the applicant’s previous convictions as aggravating. In mitigation, the wild nature of the lunge suggested a loss of temper and the judge accepted that Mr Nelson had been feeling provoked. However, she found that this fell short of the three-point test for the statutory defence of loss of control. The judge found an intention to kill, albeit that there had been some provocation.

The single ground of appeal was that the sentencing judge failed to attach significant weight to the agreed and significant provocation, falling short of loss of control, that the applicant suffered in the immediate lead-up to the fatal stabbing, and that the minimum term was manifestly excessive. The Crown’s Respondent’s Notice disputed that there had been agreed or significant provocation. The Crown’s position was that Mr Nelson had acted in a premeditated, considered desire for revenge. The defence of loss of control had been left to the jury, which rejected it along with other defences of accident, self-defence, and lack of intention to kill or cause really serious harm. The prosecution submitted that had the judge not reduced the minimum term for the limited provocation she found, it would have exceeded 25 years, and that the sentence passed was well within the appropriate range.

Appearing before the Court of Appeal, Mr John Bennathan QC developed the argument by submitting that there was undisputed provocation extending to a time not very long before the fatal incident. On any view, Mr Nelson had been punched on a number of occasions by the deceased, and there was evidence from an impartial member of the public who had seen the aggressive behaviour by the deceased before the incident. Mr Bennathan’s essential submission went to whether the courts should permit a gulf between sentences for manslaughter by reason of provocation and murder. He submitted that the case arguably disclosed too great a gulf and that the court was not constrained by legislation from reducing it. If the correct sentence for manslaughter by provocation in the present case would be something like less than half the minimum term imposed by the judge in respect of murder, then there was good reason for reducing the sentence even halfway to bridging that gap, reflecting the fact that there was some provocation, though insufficient to make good the defence.

The Court of Appeal, giving judgment through Lord Justice Gross, was not persuaded that the minimum term was, even arguably, manifestly excessive. Some care was needed regarding the ground of appeal’s focus on agreed and significant provocation, bearing in mind the contentions in the Respondent’s Notice that such provocation as there was was neither agreed nor significant. The court accepted that there was some provocation, as the judge had said, and approached the matter on that basis. However, the defences of self-defence and loss of control had both been rejected by the jury. Viewed in that light, the court was unable to accept that the minimum term was even arguably manifestly excessive. The judge had had the considerable benefit of trying the case and hearing all the evidence. The starting point of 25 years was necessarily undisputed. The aggravating factors would have pushed the minimum term above 25 years, but the judge had properly made a reduction for the mitigation present, bringing the minimum term imposed below, and not insignificantly below, 25 years. Ultimately, the salient feature of this case was that the applicant went home and returned armed with two knives, and with one of them he killed the deceased.

The court had not overlooked Mr Bennathan’s broader submission as to the gulf between sentences for manslaughter and those for murder. While accepting that the line between manslaughter as a result of provocation and murder may in some cases be thin, the difference in sentencing in no small measure flowed from legislative policy covering both the mandatory life sentence for murder and the starting point set by Parliament. On any view, this case was not the vehicle through which to launch some wholesale challenge to sentencing policy and levels. The court was not persuaded otherwise by the approach to age adopted in R v Peters [2005] EWCA Crim 605, to which Mr Bennathan referred and upon which he relied.

In short, the Court of Appeal refused the renewed application for leave to appeal against sentence, holding that the minimum term of 23 years for murder was not manifestly excessive and properly reflected the gravity of a premeditated fatal stabbing notwithstanding some provocation falling short of loss of control.

Bookmark
Please login to bookmark Close