Edward Johnson v Chief Constable of Bedfordshire Police [2025] EWHC 248 (KB)
- Summary
- Citing
- Cited By
Edward Johnson v The Chief Constable of Bedfordshire Police [2025] EWHC 248 (KB) was a decision of Richard Spearman KC, sitting as a Deputy Judge of the King’s Bench Division in the Media and Communications List, dismissing an application by the Claimant for an anonymity order and other derogations from open justice in his underlying claim for misuse of private information, breach of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights and breach of data protection legislation, save for a single, narrow reporting restriction relating to one specific mental health matter that the Defendant did not oppose.
The application, made by notice dated 20 November 2024, sought an anonymity order, anonymisation of material already filed in the proceedings, restrictions on access to the court file, and reporting restrictions, said to be necessary under CPR 39.2(3)(a), (c) and (g) and CPR 39.2(4), and by reference to the Claimant’s Article 8 and Article 14 Convention rights and his vulnerability arising from mental health difficulties said to amount to a disability. Master Thornett had referred the application to a judge of the Media and Communications List. At the hearing, the Deputy Judge accepted, unopposed, a discrete application for a reporting restriction on one specific mental health matter, but for the remainder dismissed the application, holding that the Claimant had not shown the derogations he sought to be necessary.
The underlying claim arose from the unauthorised filming of the Claimant by a camera crew from The Garden Productions Ltd, engaged for the Channel 4 television programme 24 Hours in Police Custody, during a police raid on his family home on 7 August 2019. The raid was carried out by Bedfordshire Police in connection with the arrest of the Claimant’s father, who together with the Claimant’s brother was subsequently charged with offences said by the prosecution to relate to a wider organised crime group involved in the supply of class A drugs and money laundering; those criminal proceedings had not come to trial by the date of the hearing. The Claimant himself was never a suspect but was present at the address and was briefly filmed; he believed the crew to be police evidence gatherers until his mother later told him they were filming for television. He was assessed by a consultant forensic psychiatrist, Dr Nuwan Galappathie, whose report described pre-existing mental health problems exacerbated by the incident and continuing anxiety that footage capable of identifying him might be broadcast. The Claimant’s solicitor described further concerns, including humiliation at being associated with his father’s and brother’s prosecution, his brother’s association with a prominent far-right figure, fear of reprisals from a criminal gang linked to the allegations, the risk of being mistaken for his father, whom he shares a name with, and a wish to protect his voluntary work coaching children. Channel 4 and The Garden Productions, though notified, did not participate in the hearing, but wrote confirming that no footage of the Claimant, disguised or otherwise, would be used in any future episode of the programme.
The claim form had been issued on 31 July 2020, close to the one-year limitation period applicable to the Human Rights Act 1998 claim, but had not been served by the date of the hearing, the parties having agreed successive extensions of time while the Claimant’s solicitors, acting under legal aid funding, investigated an indemnity agreement between the Defendant and The Garden Productions and considered joining The Garden Productions and Channel 4 as defendants. The application for anonymity was not made until shortly before the final agreed extension expired, on the basis that the Claimant’s solicitors had always intended to seek it at or before service.
For the Claimant, it was submitted that anonymity and the other derogations were necessary to enable him to vindicate his privacy rights without further loss of privacy or exacerbation of his psychiatric vulnerability, relying on Bloomberg LP v ZXC [2022] AC 1158 as to the privacy interests of those caught up in a criminal investigation, on JIH v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2011] 1 WLR 1645 as to the choice between naming a claimant and describing the nature of a claim, on Campbell v MGN Ltd [2004] 2 AC 457 for the test of what would cause substantial offence to a person of ordinary sensibilities, on Green Corns Ltd v Claverley Group Ltd [2005] EMLR 748 for the proposition that prior disclosure does not destroy a privacy claim, and on the ultimate balancing test from In re S [2005] 1 AC 593. It was suggested that the application could be treated as holding the position pending a possible review at a later stage of the litigation. For the Defendant, it was submitted, relying on C v Secretary of State for Justice [2016] UKSC 2, XXX v Camden London Borough Council [2020] EWCA Civ 1468, TT v Essex County Council [2023] EWHC 826 (Admin), R (MNL) v Westminster Magistrates’ Court [2023] EWHC 587 (Admin) and William Gardinala v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2024] EWCA Civ 1410, together with the Master of the Rolls’ Practice Guidance on interim non-disclosure orders, that open justice required identification of the principal actors in litigation, that derogations were only ever justified by a strict test of necessity established by clear and cogent evidence, and that the Claimant’s evidence fell well short of that standard, not least because his central fear, of being shown on television, had already been resolved by Channel 4’s assurances.
The Deputy Judge distinguished, following Nicklin J’s analysis in PMC v A Healthcare Board [2024] EWHC 2969 (KB), the court’s inherent power to withhold a name or information from open proceedings from the separate statutory jurisdiction, found in provisions such as section 4(2) and section 11 of the Contempt of Court Act 1981, to restrict publication of what has been said in open court, and held that establishing a case for the former would not preclude the latter, applying section 11. On the specific mental health matter, he considered it justified to restrict reporting notwithstanding the absence of an application to hold that part of the hearing in private, since the information was not necessary to understanding the issues, attracted a high degree of confidentiality, and was of no legitimate public interest.
Turning to the substantive application, the Deputy Judge held that the case in fact raised issues of considerable public interest concerning the lawfulness and propriety of police cooperation with broadcasters filming criminal investigations, a topic apparently not addressed in any previously decided case, so that the ordinary weight attaching to open justice and to naming the principal protagonist, as explained by Lord Rodger in In re Guardian News and Media Ltd [2010] 2 AC 697 and Lord Steyn in In re S, was, if anything, reinforced rather than diminished in this instance. He held that this was not a case, unlike JIH, in which refusal of anonymity would itself force disclosure of the very private information sought to be protected, since the private material in issue was the film footage itself, which would not be exposed by naming the Claimant, and any future need to restrict its use could be addressed separately. There was no evidence that refusal of anonymity would deter the Claimant from pursuing an otherwise viable claim or cause him clinical harm, the psychiatric evidence going only to the impact of the original filming and not to the effect of publicity about the litigation itself.
Applying the two-stage test in Murray v Express Newspapers plc [2009] Ch 481, as endorsed in Bloomberg LP v ZXC, the Deputy Judge accepted that the Claimant had a reasonable expectation of privacy in respect of having been filmed and its consequences for him, but rejected the suggestion that he faced a real risk of reprisals from a criminal gang as a result of being named as a claimant, holding that anyone minded to harm him because of his family connections would already have had ample opportunity to do so over the preceding five years. As to the distress and humiliation associated with being publicly linked to his father’s and brother’s prosecution and his brother’s political associations, he held, applying Gardinala, that such embarrassment was an ordinary and accepted incident of open justice rather than a sufficient basis for derogation, and that reliance on Article 14 did not alter that balance in the absence of evidence of any discriminatory effect. He noted, without founding his decision on the point, that the criminal proceedings against the Claimant’s father and brother had almost certainly already generated public hearings at which the family connection would have been apparent.
For these reasons the Deputy Judge held that, even taking the Claimant’s case on Article 8 at its highest, the interference occasioned by identification was not sufficiently serious to make the derogations sought necessary and proportionate, and dismissed the application in so far as it sought derogations from open justice, save for the discrete unopposed reporting restriction concerning the specific mental health matter, leaving any outstanding parts of the application, together with costs and permission to appeal, to be resolved when judgment was handed down or at a further hearing.
Khuja (formerly known as PNM) v Times Newspapers Ltd [2017] UKSC 49, [2019] AC 161, [2017] 3 WLR 35
Louise Tickle & Anor v The BBC & Ors [2025] EWCA Civ 42
LP v ZXC [2022] AC 1158
JIH v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2011] 1 WLR 1645
Campbell v MGN Ltd [2004] UKHL 22; [2004] 2 AC 457
Re S (FC) (a child) [2004] UKHL 47, [2005] 1 AC 593, [2004] 3 WLR 1129, [2004] 4 All ER 683
Green Corns Ltd v Claverley Group Ltd [2005] EMLR 748
XXX v Camden London Borough Council [2020] EWCA Civ 1468
TT v Essex County Council [2023] EWHC 826
R (on the application of C) v Secretary of State for Justice [2016] UKSC 2
William Gardinala v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2024] EWCA Civ 1410
Pink Floyd Music Ltd v EMI Records Ltd [2010] EWCA Civ 1429; [2011] 1 WLR 770
ex parte New Cross Building Society [1984] QB 227
Von Hannover v Germany [2005] EHRR 1
In re Guardian News and Media Ltd and ors [2010] UKSC 1, [2010] 2 AC 697
re BBC [2010] 1 AC 145
Murray v Express Newspapers plc [2008] EWCA Civ 446; [2009] Ch 481
Gulati v MGN Limited [2015] EWHC 1482
Representative Claimants v MGN Limited [2015] EWCA Civ 1291
ex parte Westminster Press Ltd [1985] 1 WLR 708
Scott v Scott [1913] AC 417
AMM v HXW [2010] EWHC 2457 (QB)
R (MNL) v Westminster Magistrates’ Court [2023] EWHC 587 (Admin)